M ling and chihyu shih, confucianism with a liberal face. He is the author of confucian democracy in east asia. Today, bureaucracy is the administrative system governing any large institution, whether publicly owned or privately. Sources of regime legitimacy in confucian societies introduction the concept of regime legitimacy is central to the understanding of modern political life. Sungmoon kim is associate professor of political theory at city university of hong kong. A critical study of confucianism and democratization in. But much of the world still lives by confucian ethics. This definition of democracy is intentionally loose to accommodate different types of democratic arrangements so that liberal democracy and confucian democracy can be compared in a meaningful way. With the spring academic term finished, i am in japan and china, ostensibly to give papers at several japanese and chinese universities, but really to learn more about meritocracy debates in contemporary asia.
This essay argues that confucianism is not compatible with liberal democratic values, and that the rise. Of, relating to, or characteristic of confucius, his teachings, or his followers. This essay explores the possible constructive role of a confucian metaphysics in the pluralistic confucian democratic context of south korea. I wrote a paper in may 2008 that sketches the possibility for a confucian constitutional democracy in china. This article discusses what traditional confucian political theory represents and how it is reconstructed by contemporary confucians to cope with the various challenges that it faces in modern times. More than three decades after the third wave of democratization began to spread from southern europe, much less than half the countries six of sixteen in the region meet the minimum criteria. Western political philosophy, confucian political philosophy. Since the 1990s, after the rise of china as a global power, confucianism is increasingly defended as a political alternative to liberal and democratic values. Confucian cultural traditions than is the western democratic model. Center for the study of democracy, 3151 social science plaza, university of california, irvine, ca 926975100 abstract the singaporean patriarch lee kuan yew popularized the argument that asian values derived from confucian cultural traditions are inconsistent with the development of democracy in east asia. Confucian philosophy definition of confucian philosophy. Tans deweyan reconstruction of confucianism proves to be a very fruitful and stimulating dialogue between east and west.
Confucian democracy is considered oxymoronic because. Variously described as tradition, a philosophy, a religion, a humanistic or rationalistic religion, a way of governing, or simply a way of life, confucianism developed from what was later called the hundred schools of thought from the teachings of the chinese philosopher confucius 551479 bce. Throughout the history of western democracy, there has been a tension between the eligibility and competency of the masses and. In this sense, the word confucianism is a misnomer for the tradition that is normally referred to as ru jia, ru jiao, ru xue or simply as ru in china and other east asian countries. A pluralist reconstruction of confucian democracy, dao, 2012, 11, 3. Sources of regime legitimacy in confucian societies.
This essay argues that confucianism is not compatible with liberal. Toward a confucian perspective introduction the relation between democracy and confucianism has been a subject of controversy ever since the western idea of democracy was introduced to china in the late nineteenth century. It offers an interesting case for thinking about confucian democracy and constitutionalism because its liberaldemocratic institutions are compatible with and profoundly influenced by the confucian habit of the heart. The mandate was formulated during the early period of the zhou dynasty to justify the overthrow of the shang dynasty and to legitimate the rule of the zhou kings. Economic development tends to be followed by political liberalization. This essay explores the possible constructive role of a confucian metaphysics in the pluralistic confuciandemocratic context of south korea. Variously described as tradition, a philosophy, a religion, a humanistic or rationalistic religion, a way of governing, or simply a way of life, confucianism developed from what was later called the hundred schools of thought from the teachings of the chinese philosopher.
Ap tans deweyan reconstruction of confucian democracy has led her into an exploration of the historical encounter between china and pragmatist philosophy beginning with john deweys visit to china between 1919 and 1921, of how cultural differences lead to a chinese pragmatism that differs from its american cousin even though. The role of confucianism in contemporary south korean society 33 te in classic chinese is a manifestation of the principle of heaven, inherently present in every sentient being. In this sense, the word confucianism is a misnomer for the tradition that is normally referred to as ru jia, ru jiao, ru xue or simply as. Confucian philosophy synonyms, confucian philosophy pronunciation, confucian philosophy translation, english dictionary definition of confucian philosophy. It seems inappropriate to start with a monocular definition of confucianism or democracy because such an approach will exclude others. Contributors fred dallmayr, packey j dee professor emeritus of philosophy and political science, university of notre dame. By doing so, the king acknowledged he was bound by law, like others, and granted his subjects legal rights. Kims aim is to articulate a philosophically credible and politically realistic vision of what confucian democracy can be in twentyfirstcentury east asia. Nevertheless, i stillwant to argue that the idea of asian, or, more accurately, confucian, values be taken seriously when considering ways of justifying democracy in east asian contexts.
In fact, he has said that westernstyle democracy would have deleterious effects in a society like that of singapore, encouraging permissiveness, social instability, and economically irrational decision making. Aug 15, 2011 capitalism is not the same as confucianism. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. The role of confucianism in contemporary south korean society. The book wrestles with the practical meaning of liberal rights under the korean confucian societal culture and illuminates a way. My method is to observe political thought in history and through the history of political thought. On the democracy side, there is a good case to be made that a society, even one that tends toward strongly liberal values of personal choice among a range of conceptions of the good life, must foster certain values that favor some. Zhang junmai, for example, ac centuates how conducive confucian tradition is to developing civic virtues. Confucianism was created solely by confucius and confucianism was sustained exclusively by the faith in confucius. Confucianism, also known as ruism, is a system of thought and behavior originating in ancient china. Historically and comparatively, we can evaluate the principal constructs and outcomes of democratic processes in different periods and societies. Specifically, huntington regarded the two concepts as being fundamentally contradictory because a democratic tradition of rights against the state is absent in confucian societies due to an overemphasis on harmony, cooperation, order and respect huntington 1991a, 24.
There has been a heated debate going on there among political theorists about the forms of governance most consistent with ancient confucian political thought. If to these authors confucian values are incompatible with the democratic ones, to shin 2012 and to fukuyama 1995 there are some aspects within confucian civilization favorable to democracy. Taking this idea more seriously may help us to understand why western leaders. Confucian philosophy for ideological purposes is well founded. As the issue of chinese and confucian influences touches on the question of national identity, it is. Chinese philosopher who promoted a system of social and political ethics emphasizing order, moderation, and reciprocity. Through the 1980s confucian studies in the united states tended to present confucianism as compatible with liberal democratic values.
Using both confucian texts and the work of american pragmatist john dewey, this book offers a distinctly confucian model of democracy. If to these authors confucian values are incompatible with the democratic ones, to shin 2012 and to fukuyama 1995 there are some aspects within confucian civilization favorable to. Through a detailed study of relevant concepts and theories in confucianism and john deweys pragmatist philosophy, this book illustrates the possibility of confucian democracy and offers an alternative to western liberal models. Confucian democracy is a contradictory term huntington 1991b. Sometimes viewed as a philosophy and sometimes as a religion, confucianism may be understood as an allencompassing way of thinking and living that entails ancestor reverence and a profound humancentred religiousness. See rawls, john, political liberalism, expanded ed. Confucianism is an ethics tied intimately with political philosophy.
Even today scholars have reached no consensus on this issue. Jul 06, 2018 jan 8, 2007 democracy is incompatible with confucianism, and that the latter of incompatibility between confucianism and democracy than many people this paper argues for the pragmatic construction of confucian democracy by showing chinese philosophers who desire democracy for china would do. All in all her book is a remarkable achievement and one that will prove invaluable as the meaning of global philosophy evolves over the coming decades. In contemporary confucian political theory, there is surprisingly little effort among the theorists to illuminate the value of democracy. Many societies throughout the world aim at working for the group. Political confucianism and multivariate democracy in east.
Li the ritual conduct is one of the key aspects of te in human society. For instance, deweyan confucian communitarian democrats understand democracy exclusively in terms of a way of life i. My method is to observe political thought in history and through the his. Reassessing the asian values debate today, east asia represents a region of democratic underdevelopment. Is this kind of democracy compatible with chinese tradition in. A pluralist reconstruction of confucian democracy springerlink. Thus constitutional democracy is required by the internal development of the moral spirit in chinese culture. She does so through a meticulous engagement with the best of scholarship on confucius and dewey, and in the process she also uncovers new layers. Of course, the differences between the confucian and islamic traditions are manifold. Chang yunshik notes, while liberal democracy is inconsistent with certain confucian values and has proved to lead to authoritarianism in south korea, confucian democracy holds great promise for developing democratic institutions with an emphasis on mutuality. Others, including a prominent former grand justice, assert that taiwan is a confucian society. Chaihark hahm, professor of law, yonsei university.
In his recent landmark study, sungmoon kim has argued that south korean democracy is sustained by a public culture of civility that is grounded in confucian habits and mores and yet is pluralistic in ethos. Sungmoon kims book offers an important and passionate defense of democracy, especially as it applies to east asian countries. In this paper, i argue that, given democracys dual aspects as a political system and as a way of life, it has both instrumental. There has been a heated debate going on there among political theorists about the forms of governance most consistent with ancient. The essence of postwar modernization theory is correct.
These remarks reiterate the view articulated in the book that the rise of modern democracy signifies more than just the expansion of the number of rulers, but rather a basic paradigm shift involving multiple dimensions of life and thought comprising political, metaphysical, and even theological dimensions. For some chinese, the economic success of confucian and authoritarian societies challenges the idea that wholesale adoption of western beliefs such as democracy are requisite for economic success. Joseph chan, professor, department of politics and public administration, the university of hong kong. Confucian democracy holds great promise for developing democratic institutions with an emphasis on mutuality. Confucian perspective, electoral democracy has many deficiencies and flaws, while deliberative democracy is a more acceptable form of government and decisionmaking.
John deweys second asian mission 1 a pragmatic proposal the widespread skepticism of both asians and westerners with respect to the realization of a confucianstyle democracy is rooted in two allied convictions. There may be deeper reasons to be serious about such a combination, on both the democracy and confucian sides. Her definition of confucian democracy, the similarities and differences she identifies from confucianism and deweyan pragmatism, and the ways she suggests. By confucian standards in fact, capitalism is a path towar d social disharmony. Jan 8, 2007 democracy is incompatible with confucianism, and that the latter of incompatibility between confucianism and democracy than many people this paper argues for the pragmatic construction of confucian democracy by showing chinese philosophers who desire democracy for china would do. A deweyan reconstruction, sorhoon tan offers a brilliant essay in comparative philosophy that singlehandedly restores depth, nuance, and importance to this still key concept.
In the early 1900s, scholars like liang qichao conflated democracy and power. Legitimacy by definition concerns how power may be used in ways that citizens consciously recognize and accept. Confucian political theory in contemporary china annual. Pdf the debate over the future of east asian democracy centers largely. Sungmoon kims confucian democracy in east asia is a deep, subtle, and beautifully written examination of two contested concepts, democracy and confucianism. It moves the current debate on the topic from the question of whether democracy is relevant to, and compatible with, the east asian context, to the question of the particular mode of confucian democracy that is suitable for east asia 247. Works arguing that there are elements of democracy in.
Liberal collectivism and participatory politics in south korea by sungmoon kim dissertation submitted to the faculty of the graduate school of the university of maryland, college park, in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of doctor of philosophy 2007 advisory committee. According to the text that is the most reliable guide to the teachings of confucius, the analects lunyu, he took the mandate of heaven tianming as a guide. Ap tans deweyan reconstruction of confucian democracy has led her into an exploration of the historical encounter between china and pragmatist philosophy beginning with john deweys visit to china between 1919 and 1921, of how cultural differences lead to a chinese pragmatism that differs from its american cousin even though they share certain commonalities. Confucianism, a western term that has no counterpart in chinese, is a worldview, a social ethic, a political ideology, a scholarly tradition, and a way of life. Confucian definition of confucian by the free dictionary. This paper presents confucian democracy against the background of the politics of. When they do on rare occasions, their focus is largely on democracys instrumental contribution to confucian goods. I wrote last week that the ccp chinese communist party will either open the government to multiparty elections, or will eventually be overthrown i want to provide more detail on exactly why i believe this, and on a possible route to this reform i think is possible. A critical study of confucianism and democratization in east asia. In this paper, i attempt to revamp confucian democracy, which is originally presented as the communitarian corrective and cultural alternative to western liberal democracy, into a robust democratic political theory and practice that is plausible in the societal context of pluralism. Islamic and confucian thinkers have been trying for some time to work out the relations between. Specifically, i examine the school of new confucianism in taiwan and hong kong, political confucianism and civic confucianism in mainland china, and the theory of confucian.
757 1336 81 834 942 542 643 1187 228 1557 1296 1022 1471 856 1040 955 902 152 1112 76 88 1365 443 904 1234 900 1475 1212 352 525 482 1317 1429 124